Friday, June 14, 2019

RESOLVING THE GAP IN ACCESS TO EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION THROUGH UNIVERSAL CHILD GRANTS PROGRAMME IN RWANDA


Rwanda is one of the sub-Saharan African countries that demonstrably achieved MDGs performance indicators of progress in education. Inclusive education in Rwanda follows a rights based approach whereby every child regardless of their economic status or sex has access to school. The universal primary and 12 Year Basic Education (12YBE) programme has addressed access and equity constraints yielding to increased enrolment and encouraging effects at national level. The highest participation rate of 98.7% is observed in population aged between 7 and 12 years. The Rwandan legal framework that promotes education for all shows strong commitment towards meeting the rights of children to education. Following the ratification of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UN CRC) coupled with the ambition of becoming a knowledge based economy, the Government of Rwanda (GoR) has invested in and initiated several steps in the direction of addressing the rights and needs of children in the country.  Participation in primary school is the highest at 98.7% observed in population aged between 7 and 12 years (official school age for primary education).

Whereas the GoR has promoted basic education, a visible gap in promoting and provision of services in Pre-Primary Education (PPE) persists in practice, despite fairly supportive education legislation. The Sustainable Development Goals’ agenda now invites the extension of this success in primary education be strengthened with comparable achievement at the pre-primary level (UNICEF, 2015).

According to the education statistics year book, Gross Enrolment Rate (GER) in PPE has grown steadily over the years increasing from 16% for boys and 17% for girls in 2008 to 23.7% for boys and 24.1% for girls in 2017.  Net enrolment rate (NER) for both boys and girls remains lower compared to GER by a difference of 4%. Obscuring factors in pre-primary were reported as follows: Funding of pre-primary services at national level remains low accounting for only 0.4% of the national education budget. Low investments in PPEs have called for a fee-based education programme in the country yet other education levels are fee-free. Pre-Primary Education is largely financed by parents who contribute towards paying teacher salaries. The contribution for teacher reimbursement in Rwanda creates disparities in PPE attendance because of household inability to afford the contributions. By 2010, poverty incidence in Rwanda was at 44.9% while extreme poverty was at 24%. According to integrated household living survey data, income poverty incidence was reported to as 16.4% in 2013/14 for children between age of 0-4. This makes PPE expenditure a luxury for the majority Rwandan households. Also, considering its post conflict context, households’ perception of the importance of PPE is still a deterrent to access. Child Grants and other social protection benefits, in several countries, have been found to elicit and motivate positive behavior for child-related beneficial outcomes. This paper posits that introducing a Universal Child Grant in Rwanda, conditioned on access to PPE would be a viable policy solution that would further bolster the PPE GER.   It examines and analyses the impacts that Child Grants have had on ECE globally and the Rwandan Social Protection policy context and suggests ways that UCG would increase Social Protection coverage for Children while also increasing their access to PPE.

14 comments:

  1. Hi Francisca, this is interesting observation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Cisca, thanks for the intresting analysis. Accessibility and affordability is still a challenge to PPE.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Cisca, thanks for the intresting analysis. Accessibility and affordability is still a challenge to PPE.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Merci beaucoup pour ton analyse et ton implication dans la formation de la jeunesse du Rwanda et de notre Afrique. Courage

    ReplyDelete
  5. Francisca, Merci pour cette analyse et ton implication dans la formation de la jeunesse au Rwanda et pour notre Afrique. Courage

    ReplyDelete
  6. Francisca, merci beaucoup pour ton analyse et ton implication dans la formation ddes jeunes au Rwanda et pour notre Afrique. Courage

    ReplyDelete
  7. A tree is as strong as its roots. In the same way, a strong education must start with PPE. I strongly support your argument. A great observation, Francisca!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Francesca, thank you for shading light on this vital issue. A knowledge based economy is a composite of the people with ability to competitively extract information and make good use of it. A good example is you! Preparing our children to be able to excel in these skills is an intentional process and PPE is the bedrock to achieving this. This article for sure dwelt on enrollment but I find a meat on the statement "The contribution for teacher reimbursement in Rwanda creates disparities in PPE attendance because of household inability to afford the contributions". I was in Jali Sector two days ago. I found a great PPE facility. Reading your article worries me now! The quality of any education offering is as good as it's offer 'the teacher. If the teachers are not certain of income we cannot be certain of good yield from our little angles who attend PPE. Also lets not forget the basic principles, parents will demand PPE if they see a difference in having a child attend. If the quality offered is below a value of having a child join the parents on farm lands the GER will reflect that. PPE needs to be made attractive and we'll served ECE Teachers will serve the children well in return. Thanks again to bring this picture to light.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Nice piece. In Kinyarwanda it is said that "Umwana apfa mu iterura" literally meaning that a child may be spoilt at his/her early stages of growth. At such a stage as PPE, a child needs more care than ever as it is at that stage that child according to Sigmund Freud starts to discover a lot and acquires more knowledge than before or after. Thanks Francisca for your inspiration.

    ReplyDelete
  10. A very well research and in depth observation. Keep up and bring up more observations. It really have a positive impact in our social, educational life. I encourage you.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I don't agree with those who say there is lack of funds to finance early childhood education. another reason given is that the sector is complex to manage. how is this so? what i see PPE hasn't given the attention it deserves and yet it is the most important programme that will support the development of long-term productivity growth of our nation.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Low demand for PPE services, limited supply of PPE services and poor quality of PPE services remain the major problematic factors in the sector. The response to these issues is prioritization and INCREASED financing of the PPE programme. @ Anne-marie, you may know know this better than my self. Evidence from economic analysis shows that substantial economic returns through productivity gains in the workforce and cost saving to society can be gained from investments in PPE. The other complementary services such as health, nutrition and psycho social support in early childhood and in sub-subsequent life cycle stages multiply these developmental benefits.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This is a decent analysis that needs a further dissemination indeed! Kudos Francesca

    ReplyDelete